Waiting in Line

There are roughly 1.3 million children on Medicaid in New York City. How many child psychologists are available to treat them?

The pandemic has put a unique strain on everyone's mental health, especially young people. Lockdowns, remote school, distanced relationships, grief—all have brought about increased anxiety and depression in children. The Centers for Disease Control estimated that before the pandemic one out of every five children were living with a mental health disorder, and that just a fraction of them them were receiving care from a specialized provider.

The CDC estimates that

80% of children and adolescents

living with a mental health disorder

like anxiety or depression

never recieve treatment.

 

The CDC estimates that

80% of children and adolescents

living with a mental health disorder

like anxiety or depression

never recieve treatment.

 

Clinical psychologists are one of a few important specialized providers who can diagnose and treat mental health issues. How accessible are these providers to the nearly 1.3 million children who rely on Medicaid in New York City?

1 psychologist

Source: health.data.ny.gov “Medicaid Enrolled Provider Listing” as of March 2022

There are 1,876 clinical psychologists in network with New York Medicaid.

111 of them primarily specialize* in treating children and adolescents.

And 47 of those child & adolescent psychologists work in New York City.


While New York City has the highest concentration of child psychologists in the state, it is also home to half of all children on New York Medicaid.

If you were to divide those 47 psychologists among the almost 1.3 million children and teenagers on Medicaid in the city, it would look something like this.


1 child & adolescent psychologist for every:

125 children

2,000 children

4,000 children

6,000 children

8,000 children

10,000 children

12,000 children

14,000 children

16,000 children

18,000 children

20,000 children

22,000 children

24,000 children

26,000 children

27,500 children

Source: health.data.ny.gov “Medicaid Program Enrollment by Month Beginning 2009”

Aug. 2021 enrollment

1 child & adolescent psychologist

for every:

125 children

2,000 children

4,000 children

6,000 children

8,000 children

10,000 children

12,000 children

14,000 children

16,000 children

18,000 children

20,000 children

22,000 children

24,000 children

26,000 children

27,500 children

Source: health.data.ny.gov “Medicaid Program Enrollment

by Month Beginning 2009” | Aug. 2021 enrollment

That's one child and adolescent psychologist for every 27,500+ young people on Medicaid. And New York City only has the fourth worst rate of every economic region in the state. Mohawk Valley, for example, has only one child psychologist for the 58,000 children on Medicaid in the entire region.





Methodology

I cross referenced the New York State Medicaid provider database with the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid NPI directory. I checked every NPI number listed as "clinical psychologist" in the New York Medicaid directory, and tallied the providers listing "child and adolescent psychology" as their primary taxonomy.

To get a rate of providers for the children on Medicaid in a region, I used the most recent New York Medicaid enrollee data (August 2021) broken down by economic region and age group. Children constituted enrollees ages 0-20.

Quantifying the pay gap for private and Medicaid mental health providers -->